Fisioter Bras 2021;2293):398-411
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Health impacts on cancer patients: an overview of the
COVID-19 pandemic in Brazil
Impactos
na saúde do paciente oncológico: um panorama da pandemia por COVID-19 no Brasil
Andréa
Felinto Moura*, Kellyane Munick Rodrigues Soares Holanda**, Natália Roque Maia de
Sousa***, Márcio Higor Vasconcelos Irineu***, Maria
Paula Ribeiro Barbosa***, Nayanna Moreira de Araujo****, Daniela Gardano Bucharles Mont’Alverne*****
*Centro
Universitário Maurício de Nassau – UNINASSAU, Campus Parangaba, Fortaleza, CE, Brazil, **Hospital Infantil Albert Sabin, Fortaleza, CE, Brazil, ***Faculdade de Medicina - FAMED, Universidade
Federal do Ceará, Fortaleza, CE, Brazil, ****Santa
Casa da Misericórdia de Fortaleza, Fortaleza, CE, Brazil,*****Departamento de
Fisioterapia - DEFISIO, Universidade Federal do Ceará, Fortaleza, CE, Brazil
Received:
April 16, 2021; Accepted: June
21, 2021.
Correspondence: Andréa Felinto Moura, Centro
Universitário Maurício de Nassau, Campus Parangaba, 60740-005 Fortaleza CE, Brazil, andreafmoura@gmail.com
Natália Roque Maia de Sousa:
nataliaroquefisioterapia@gmail.com
Márcio Higor Vasconcelos Irineu:
marciofisio98@gmail.com
Maria Paula Ribeiro Barbosa: mpaularibeirobarbosa@gmail.com
Nayanna Moreira de Araujo: nayannamoreiraa@gmail.com
Daniela Gardano Bucharles
Mont’Alverne: daniela.gardano@hotmail.com
Abstract
Introduction: Because of the
social isolation during the COVID-19 pandemic, the use of health services and
the participation in social activities of cancer patients have been reduced,
which can have a direct impact on their health. Objective: To identify
the repercussions on the cancer treatment, participation in social activities
and emotional state of cancer patients in Brazil during COVID-19 pandemic. Methods:
This is a cross-sectional study using an online questionnaire for cancer
patients. A non-probability sample was recruited by convenience. Sociodemographic
and clinical data, physical activity levels and emotional state (DASS-21)
during the pandemic were collected. Quantitative data were analyzed and the
significance level set at 95% (p < 0.05). Results: A total of 105
individuals participated in the study. Results indicated that younger
participants were more stressed; 16.2% reported interrupting cancer treatment
and 42.9% cancelled examinations or appointments during the pandemic,
associated with a higher rate of stress, anxiety, and depression. More than
half of the individuals engaged in exercise before the pandemic, but only 35.2%
did so in the previous 2 months. Physical exercise during the pandemic was
associated with lower depression score. Conclusion: As observed
worldwide, the COVID-19 pandemic has had a direct impact on the physical and
mental health of cancer patients in Brazil.
Keywords: COVID-19; cancer; anxiety;
depression; stress.
Resumo
Introdução: Como consequência do isolamento social
durante a pandemia de COVID-19, reduziu-se a utilização de serviços de saúde e
a participação em atividades sociais de pacientes com câncer, o que pode
impactar diretamente em sua saúde. Objetivo: Identificar as repercussões
no tratamento do câncer, na participação em atividades sociais e no estado emocional
de pacientes com câncer no Brasil durante a pandemia de COVID-19. Métodos:
Trata-se de um estudo transversal com questionário online para pacientes com
câncer. Uma amostra não probabilística foi recrutada por conveniência. Dados
sociodemográficos e clínicos, níveis de atividade física e estado emocional
(DASS-21) durante a pandemia foram coletados. Os dados quantitativos foram
analisados ??e o nível de significância estabelecido em 95% (p <0,05). Resultados:
Participaram do estudo 105 indivíduos. Os resultados indicaram que os
participantes mais jovens estavam mais estressados; 16,2% relataram interrupção
do tratamento contra o câncer e 42,9% cancelaram exames ou consultas durante a
pandemia, associado a maior índice de estresse, ansiedade e depressão. Mais da
metade dos indivíduos praticou exercícios antes da pandemia, mas apenas 35,2% o
fizeram nos 2 meses anteriores. O exercício físico durante a pandemia foi
associado a menor escore de depressão. Conclusão: Conforme observado em
todo o mundo, a pandemia de COVID-19 teve impacto direto na saúde física e
mental de pacientes com câncer no Brasil.
Palavras-chave: COVID-19; câncer; ansiedade,
depressão, estresse.
The epidemic
caused by the new coronavirus originated in Wuhan, China at the end of 2019 and
assumed catastrophic proportions worldwide. The growing rates of contamination
and deaths led the World Health Organization to consider it a pandemic in March
2020. After being infected, individuals may manifest mild or severe symptoms,
with systemic damage affecting different organs depending on the individual
reaction of the immunological system [1].
The presence of
comorbidities, such as cardiovascular diseases, diabetes
and cancer, make individuals more vulnerable to viral infection complications
caused by the new coronavirus, progressing to the most severe form of the
disease [2]. According to the National Cancer Institute (INCA), cancer patients
undergoing chemotherapy or radiotherapy treatment, submitted to surgery in the previous
year or using immunosuppressant drugs, belong to the high-risk group [3].
Recent studies have found that these patients exhibit a worse prognosis when
infected by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (Sars-CoV-2), in
addition to high death rates [4].
Given the high
contagion levels and the severity with which the disease can affect part of the
population, several countries adopted preventive and control measures, social
isolation being one of the main strategies [2,5]. Thus, since the onset of the
pandemic, institutional changes in health services have occurred throughout the
world in terms of the ongoing treatment of several conditions, including cancer
treatment [6]. As a result, the contact of cancer patients with health professionals
and their use of health services have been lower than before the pandemic [7].
However,
evidence shows that to obtain satisfactory outcomes, no stage of cancer
treatment should be interrupted, even though the likelihood of contamination is
high when patients leave social isolation to undergo treatment at health
facilities. This situation causes a paradigm between the current pandemic and
treatment adherence [8]. Additionally, social isolation resulted in lower
participation in social activities and less interaction with family and
friends, an essential emotional support network for cancer patients, thereby
compromising their well-being [9]. An aggravating factor is that cancer
patients are more likely to display psychic manifestations when compared to the
general population. These include depression and anxiety during diagnosis and
treatment, negatively impacting the quality of life of these individuals [10].
Thus, given the
current situation, it is important to assess the impacts and identify the
emergence of possible manifestations of anxiety, depression, stress, and other
symptoms in cancer patients, resulting from the crisis caused by the new
coronavirus. Thus, the aim of the present study was to assess the impact of
COVID-19 on the follow-up of cancer treatment, as well as participation in
social activities, such as physical exercise, to identify the repercussion of
this scenario on the emotional state of patients diagnosed with cancer in
Brazil.
Study design
This is a
cross-sectional study conducted using an online questionnaire for patients with
cancer, to collect data on the perceptions and repercussions of their treatment
during the COVID-19 pandemic. The study was conducted in line with National
Health Council Resolution 466/12. After approval by the Research Ethics
Committee of the Federal Universidade Federal do Ceará (4.084.326), data were collected on a
questionnaire applied through social media in July and August 2020.
Population and sample
The population
was composed of individuals diagnosed with cancer. Individuals were invited to
participate in the study via a link that contained the questionnaire
disseminated in social media. Non-probability sampling by convenience
(“snowball”) was used. Included were patients with cancer, irrespective of the
type and stage of the disease, diagnosed before or during the onset of the
pandemic in Brazil (February 2020), regardless of sex, aged 18 years or older.
Data collection instrument
A questionnaire
was created by the researchers and applied online. Participants were initially
invited to access the formula and provide written informed consent. Those who
declined were directed to a thank you page.
The questions
addressed social and demographic questions related to the health status of
cancer patients during the COVID-19 pandemic, including type of cancer, time
since diagnosis, interventions, and possible treatment discontinuation due to
the pandemic. In addition, the presence of flu symptoms and COVID-19 diagnosis
was investigated, as well as the impact of the pandemic on the physical
activity levels of cancer patients. Also assessed was the emotional state of
these individuals using the Depression, Anxiety and Stress Scale (DASS-21).
The original
DASS contains 42 items divided into three factors. However, a shorter version
of the instrument containing 21 items (DASS-21) has been applied in different
countries and translated and validated for Portuguese [11]. DASS-21 is a set of
three self-reported 4-point Likert subscales, each consisting of 7 items that
evaluate the emotional states of depression, anxiety, and stress.
Statistical analysis
The paired
student’s t-test for normally distributed data (parametric) was used to analyze
and compare the measures and the Wilcoxon test for non-normal distribution
(non-parametric). Pearson’s and Spearman’s correlation coefficients for
parametric and nonparametric variables, respectively, were applied to determine
the existence of a relationship between the variables.
Quantitative
variables were tabulated and analyzed using the SPSS (Statistical Pack for the
Social Sciences) program, version 23.0. The results were presented in tables
and analyzed descriptively using the mean and standard deviation. The
significance level was set at 95% (p < 0.05).
A total of 105
individuals (96 women and 9 men) diagnosed with cancer took part in the study.
Table I contains the demographic data and clinical characteristics of the study
participants. The average age, weight and BMI of the subjects was 39 ± 12.2
years, 70.1 ± 17.5 kg, and 26.8 ± 7.3 kg/m2, respectively. Most of
the patients were from the Northeast (27.6%) and Southeast (28.6%) of Brazil,
married (52.4%), with an average of 1.2 ± 1.1 children.
With respect to
type of cancer, 50.5% were diagnosed with breast cancer and 20% hematological
and lymphatic cancer. The other individuals reported a varied diagnosis in
terms of tumor location, including urogynecological,
lung, bone, gastrointestinal tract (GIT), head and neck and metastatic. The
average time since diagnosis was 0.93 ± 0.97 years, demonstrating a positive
correlation between age and time since diagnosis (r = 0.308, p = 0.001). Among
the participants, 92.4% had started chemotherapy treatment, 59% had undergone
surgery to remove tumors, 48.6% had been submitted to radiotherapy, 3.8% to
transplant and 23.8% to hormone therapy (Table I).
Table I - Demographic
data and clinical characteristics of the cancer patients
BMI = body mass index;
GIT = gastrointestinal tract
The Depression,
Anxiety and Stress Scale (DASS-21) was used to assess the emotional state of
participants during the pandemic. The average score for depression was 4.75 ±
4.25, anxiety 4.5 ± 3.9 and stress 7.4 ± 4.75, showing a positive correlation
between the depression and anxiety scores (r = 0.659, p = 0.000) and stress (r
= 0.758, p = 0.000), as well as between anxiety and stress (r = 0.752, p =
0.000).
These scores
were correlated with age and time since diagnosis. There was a negative
correlation between age and stress (r = -0.206, p = 0.035), in which the
younger the age, the greater the stress, and no significant correlation was
observed between time since diagnosis and the emotional state of the
individuals. Furthermore, the emotional state of the patients was assessed
according to the type of treatment, including chemotherapy, radiotherapy, and
surgery. Individuals submitted to surgery were more anxious than nonsurgical
patients (p = 0.002) (Table II). There was no association between chemotherapy
and radiotherapy and emotional state.
Table II - Associations
between anxiety, depression, and stress of cancer patients in relation to
previous surgery
DASS-21 = Depression,
Anxiety and Stress Scale; *p < 0.05
To assess the
impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the medical follow-up and cancer treatment
of these individuals, they were questioned regarding treatment abandonment and
examination or appointment cancellation due to the pandemic. Only 16.2% (n =
17) of individuals reported abandoning cancer treatment. However, 42.9% (n =
45) cancelled examinations or appointments in this period. An association
between this aspect and emotional state demonstrated that individuals who
cancelled examinations and appointments obtained higher stress (p = 0.002),
depression (p = 0.002) and anxiety (p = 0.011) scores (Table III).
Table III - Associations
between anxiety, depression and stress of cancer patients who cancelled
appointments and examinations during the COVID-19 pandemic
*p < 0.05
Most
participants (92.4%) reported being fearful of coronavirus contamination, but
only 3.8% of these individuals were diagnosed with COVID-19 and did not require
hospitalization. The individuals were also questioned about symptoms, such as
cough, fever, diarrhea, shortness of breath, sore throat, and body aches in the
previous 2 months, and more than half (55.2%, n = 58) exhibited no symptoms.
However, 9.5% reported dry cough, 7.6% fever, 13.3% diarrhea, 6.7% shortness of
breath, 16.2% sore throat and 29.5% body aches.
Three of the
four individuals diagnosed with COVID-19 during this period reported fever, two
dry cough, shortness of breath and body aches, and one
diarrhea and sore throat. An association between symptoms and emotional state
revealed that those with no symptoms were less anxious (p = 0.043). However,
there was no association between symptoms and depression and stress scores
(Table IV).
Table IV - Associations
between the anxiety, depression, and stress of cancer patients with no symptoms
during the COVID-19 pandemic
*p < 0.05
Participants
were also questioned about physical activity before and during the COVID-19
pandemic, which is also associated with the DASS-21 questionnaire. More than
half (n = 53, 50.5%) engaged in physical activity before the pandemic, but
during the pandemic only 37 individuals (35.2%) had exercised in the previous 2
months. The association between emotional state and physical activity during
the pandemic showed that those who did not engage in physical activity obtained
a higher depression score (p = 0.03). However, there was no association between
anxiety and stress scores and engaging in exercise (Table V).
Table V - Associations
between the anxiety, depression and stress of cancer patients and physical
activity during the COVID-19 pandemic
*p < 0.05
In addition,
most participants reported feeling tired (n = 93, 88.6%) and a direct impact on
their quality of life (n = 102, 97.2%) during this period. However, there was
no significant association between feeling tired and engaging in physical
activity.
The present
study sought to assess the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the overall
health status of cancer patients, identifying the influence of the social
isolation period on the continuity of cancer treatment, scheduling appointments
and examinations, physical activity level and the emotional state of these
individuals. The sample consisted primarily of young adult women diagnosed with
cancer in the previous year. A large portion of the participants reported an
impact of the pandemic on their quality of life and fear of contamination with
the new coronavirus.
At the time of
this study, Brazil had recorded nearly 100,000 deaths from COVID-19. The
disease is present in 98.8% of Brazilian municipalities, with a mortality rate
that ranged from 6.9% (May) to 3.4% (August) [12]. Studies have demonstrated
that the new coronavirus outbreak triggered not only the risk of contracting
the disease and dying, but also psychological problems due to strict social
isolation, which gradually separates people and changes their routines, as well
as the critical situation of collapsed health systems associated with the fear
of contamination [13,14].
A study
conducted in Italy at the onset of the pandemic assessed the perception of
young cancer patients (between 15 and 21 years) regarding the risk of
contamination and stress levels and found that many individuals were fearful of
being contaminated and developing serious complications from the disease, which
may be related to the higher stress levels of these patients [15]. In the
present study, correlating between the variables and emotional state showed
that the younger the individuals, the more stressed they were.
Cancer patients
are at risk of being contaminated with the coronavirus because of their greater
likelihood of developing a severe form of the disease [16,17]. Thus, fear of
contamination may have been the primary factor that raised the number of cancelled
appointments and examinations in the present study, given that more than 90% of
participants expressed fear of being contaminated with the new coronavirus.
This may have had a direct impact on the emotional state of these individuals,
who were more anxious, stressed, and depressed.
Despite the high
percentage of participants who cancelled appointments and examinations,
slightly more than 15% reported interrupting cancer treatment during the
pandemic. However, studies have demonstrated that COVID-19 has had a direct
impact on cancer treatment and that patients have experienced problems caused
by late diagnosis. Berardi et al. [18] showed that surgeries and other
procedures have been affected by the pandemic in a leading cancer center in
Italy, with a significant decline in procedures conducted in 2020 when compared
to the previous year. Another study conducted with 555 patients with ovarian
cancer found that 33% interrupted some stage of their treatment, including
delaying surgery and canceling appointments and examinations [19].
These healthcare
changes as well as other pandemic-related factors have occurred worldwide. A
study in the United Kingdom identified delays, interruptions and even changes
in cancer treatment [20]. Other studies have demonstrated an increase in
symptoms of anxiety and depression in cancer patients in Italy and China. Some
individuals met the diagnostic criteria for post-traumatic stress disorder
(PTSD), women and younger patients being the most affected [21,22]. In Holland,
the follow-up or treatment of many cancer patients changed, causing them
considerable concern [23]. Thus, extending social distancing as a preventive
measure to avoid contamination will likely have significant impacts on cancer
patients [20].
Physical
activity is a good alternative to prevent the considerable impact of the
pandemic on the emotional state and consequently the quality of life of this
population. Physical exercise is directly related to an improvement in quality
of life, muscle, and aerobic aptitude, as well as mental health, thereby
reducing the fatigue commonly experienced by these individuals [24,25].
In the present
study, individuals who engaged in physical activity in the previous 2 months
were less depressed. Moreover, those who did not exhibit flu symptoms that
could be related to COVID-19, were less depressed, anxious, and stressed. The
pandemic may have impacted the physical activities of some cancer patients,
since this study observed a decrease in the number of individuals who engaged
in physical exercise during the pandemic when compared to before it. This could
have contributed to the emotional state of the participants during the
pandemic.
Most of the
participants reported fatigue and a direct impact of the pandemic on their
quality of life during this period. However, there was no significant
correlation between fatigue and physical activity. Nevertheless, studies
demonstrate a positive contribution of physical exercise in managing treatment
side effects, in addition to increasing tolerance to them, fatigue being the
most common symptom experienced by cancer patients [26,27].
As observed
worldwide, the COVID-19 pandemic has had a direct impact on the emotional state
and quality of life of cancer patients in Brazil. The fear of contamination and
changes in diagnosis and cancer treatment may be related to the symptoms of
anxiety, depression and stress experienced by this population. The pandemic may
also have been responsible for the decline in physical activity, which could
contribute even more to the negative impact on the quality of life of these
individuals.
Funding
The research did not
receive any funding.
Conflict of interests
We certify that the
research have no affiliations with or involvement in
any organization or entity.