ORIGINAL
ARTICLE
The
effects of neuromuscular performance and perceptual parameters in futsal
athletes playing consecutive games
Efeito do desempenho
neuromuscular e dos parâmetros perceptuais em atletas de futsal em jogos
consecutivos
Cristiane Blausius Salvi Hübner1,
Cristiano André Hübner1, Martim Gomes Weber2, Fernando de
Souza Campos3, Renan Felipe Hartmann Nunes4, Gladson Flor Bertolini5, Lucinar
Jupir Forner Flores1
1Universidade Estadual do Oeste do Paraná, Marechal
Cândido Rondon, PR, Brazil
2Universidade
Estadual de Londrina, Londrina, PR, Brazil
3Marechal Futsal,
Marechal Cândido Rondon, PR, Brazil
4Departamento de Fisiologia, Clube Atlético Tubarão, Tubarão, SC, Brazil
5Universidade Estadual do Oeste do Paraná, Cascavel, PR, Brazil
Received
on: March 24th, 2020; Accepted on: June 30th, 2020.
Corresponding author: Lucinar
Jupir Forner Flores, Unioeste, Curso de Educação Física Bacharelado, Rua
Pernambuco, 1777 Centro 85960-000 Marechal Cândido Rondon PR
Cristiane
Blausius Salvi Hübner: crisblausius@gmail.com
Cristiano
André Hübner: cristianohubner@gmail.com
Martim Gomes Weber:
martim_92@hotmail.com
Fernando de Souza
Campos: campos.mn@hotmail.com
Renan Felipe Hartmann
Nunes: nunesrenan85@hotmail.com
Gladson Flor Bertolini:
gladsonricardo@gmail.com
Lucinar Jupir
Forner Flores: lucinar.flores@unioeste.br
Abstract
The
present study aims to analyze the effects of consecutive futsal games on
neuromuscular performance and rating of perceived exertion in athletes.
Fourteen male futsal players (16.5 ± 0.51 years, 67.5 ± 11.1 kg; 1.73 ± 0.08
cm; 22.5 ± 2.3 kg/m²) from a youth futsal team took part at the study. Our
research monitored the team throughout the 4-day qualifying phase of the
Campeonato Paranaense de Futsal (the Youth Futsal
Championship of the State of Paraná, Brazil). The athletes underwent the
following tests immediately after each futsal match: vertical jump test (Squat
Jump (SJ), Countermovement Jump test (CMJ), and a rating of perceived exertion
(s-RPE) session. Magnitude based inference analysis reported CMJ values likely
lower after the 2nd match when compared with the results obtained after the 1st
and 4th matches: (ES = -0.46 low) and (ES = -0.53 moderate), respectively.
Furthermore, SJ values reported after the 2nd match are likely lower if
compared with the outcomes obtained after the 1st match (ES = -0.56 moderate)
and possibly lower when compared with the 3rd matches (ES = -0.45 low). PSE
results were significantly different comparing the 1st and 2nd matches
(p = 0.04); the 1st and 3rd matches (p = 0.01); and the 3rd and 4th matches
(p = 0.01). Moreover, the outcomes research obtained after the 1st match are very
likely to be lower when compared with the results from the 2nd (ES = -0.97 high)
and 3rd matches (ES = high); and almost certain lower when compared with the 2nd
and 3rd matches (ES = -0.45 low). Test results research obtained after the 4th
match are very likely to be lower than the ones from the 2nd (EF = -0.83 high)
and 3rd matches (ES = 1.01 high). Thus, by investigating the youth futsal
tournament, the study could observe under-17 athletes delivered a decreased
performance in vertical jump tests throughout the 4-consecutive-day
championship, which can be associated with an increased rating of perceived
exertion.
Keywords: team sports; physical performance; fatigue; muscle damage.
Resumo
O objetivo do presente
estudo foi analisar os efeitos de jogos sequenciais de futsal no desempenho
neuromuscular e percepção subjetiva de esforço em atletas. Quatorze atletas do
sexo masculino (16,5 ± 0,51 anos, 67,5 ± 11,1 kg; 1,73 ± 0,08 cm; 22,5 ± 2,3 kg/m²),
pertencentes a uma equipe de futsal juvenil participaram do estudo. A equipe
foi monitorada durante a fase classificatória do Campeonato Paranaense de
Futsal, com jogos realizados em quatro dias consecutivos. Os testes de salto
vertical Squat Jump (SJ) e Counter Moviment Jump
(CMJ) e percepção subjetiva de esforço da sessão (PSE) foram realizados logo
após cada jogo. As análises de inferência baseada na magnitude demonstraram que
os valores de CMJ no jogo 2 foram provavelmente menores comparado ao jogo 1
(ES = -0,46 pequeno) e ao jogo 4 (ES = -0,53 moderado) respectivamente. Além
disso, SJ apresentou provavelmente menores valores no jogo 2 comparado ao jogo
1 (ES = -0,56 moderado) e possivelmente ao jogo 3 (ES = -0,45 pequeno). Em
relação a PSE foram encontradas diferenças significativas entre as médias relativas
dos jogos 1 e 2 (p = 0,04), 1 e 3 (p = 0,01) e 3 e 4 (p = 0,01). Além disso, o jogo 1
apresentou valores muito provavelmente e quase certo menores comparados aos
jogos 2 (ES= -0,97 grande) e 3 (ES = grande), valores possivelmente menores no
jogo 2 e 3 (ES = -0,45 pequeno) e mudanças provavelmente e muito provavelmente
menores no jogo 4 comparado ao 2 (EF = -0,83) e ao 3 (ES = 1,01 grande)
respectivamente. Em conclusão, o campeonato de futsal investigado, com jogos
realizados em quatro dias consecutivos, ocasionou diminuição de desempenho dos
testes de saltos verticais ao longo da competição associada com o aumento da
percepção de esforço em atletas sub 17 anos.
Palavras-chave: esportes coletivos;
desempenho físico; fadiga; dano muscular.
Futsal is a sport characterized by high-intensity intermittent efforts
and short recovering periods [1,2]. Moving fast and intensively is particularly
important during a match [3-5], once aerobic (power and capacity) and anaerobic
components are highly associated to an athlete’s good performance [1,2-8].
Although one’s aerobic system is predominantly important for the sport,
anaerobic ability aptitude demonstrated in actions of muscular power is related
to decisive activities within a match, such as sprint, jumps, braking,
direction changing, and kicking [1,2].
In Brazil and other countries, futsal teams can play 2-4 matches a week
on consecutive days in short tournaments [9,10]. High intense matches may lead
to delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS), inflammation, elevated subjective
perception of effort (SPE) and of muscle function in futsal athletes [2,11-13].
Though the need of adequate recovery levels for good match performance,
the resting interval in-between matches may not be long enough to enable
adequate recovery to futsal athletes [14]. Thus, vertical jump tests are
sensible to identify fatigue after a futsal match [9,14,15].
In this sense, it is important to understand the physiological impact of
consecutive matches in physical performance by analyzing athletes using
practical reliable tests. Testing allows planning adequate recovery strategies
and potentiating match performance. Therefore, the present study aims to
identify the effects of consecutive futsal matches in the neuromuscular
performance of vertical jumps and in SPE in futsal athletes.
Experimental
design
The Ethics Committee on Research (Human Beings) of the Western Paraná
State University (UNIOESTE) approved this research project. Certificate of
Presentation of Ethical Appreciation (CAAE) #52557415.0.0000.0107, decree
#1.838.509.
Participants
Fourteen male athletes (age = 16.5 ± 0.51 years, body mass = 67.5 ± 11.1
kg; height = 1.73 ± 0.08 cm; BMI = 22.5 ± 2.3 kg/m²) took part at this study.
The sample selection of the study was intentional and non-probabilistic:
inclusion criterion was being an athlete who belongs to a youth futsal team
that plays in regional and state championships.
Researchers carried out data collection throughout the classifying phase
of the Campeonato Paranaense sub 17 anos de Futsal (Youth Futsal Championship of the State
of Paraná, Brazil – under-17 male athletes). Athletes were used to
systematically practice five times a week (~90-minute training sessions), at
night, and play friendly and official games on the weekends. Athletes underwent
60 to 90-minute training sessions. Training focused on improving their
technical/tactical and physical performance (specifically concerning their
anaerobic and aerobic systems). Anaerobic training consisted of plyometric
exercises, explosive strength exercises, and multiple sprints; aerobic training
consisted of small-sided matches and running with long and short intervals.
Procedure
Participants underwent five experimental sessions with a 24-hour interval in-between sessions. In the first
session, that took place one week before data collection, researchers carried
out each athlete’s anthropometric analysis in order to characterize the sample
of the study. From the second to the fifth sessions, subjects underwent
vertical jump tests (Squat Jump (SJ)) and Countermovement Jump tests (CMJ)
immediately after each match of the futsal tournament.
A scale with a stadiometer (Balmak model Labstore – maximum load = 150 kg, minimum load = 1 kg, 50 g
scale, Class III) measured the athletes’ body mass and structure, according
with Guedes & Guedes protocol (2006) [16]: athletes were wearing their team
uniform (t-shirt, shorts, and socks – no sneakers) [16]. Research also
calculated their Body Mass Index (BMI) [17].
For the CMJ test, players stood in orthostatic position, with their
hands on their hips, flexed their knees to a self-selected angle, and performed
the concentric phase with as much power as possible. For the SJ test, players
remained in crouched position, for at least 3 seconds, with their hands on
their hips and their knees flexed at an angle of ~ 90º [18]. A Jumping Mat (Multisprint®, Hidrofit®, Brazil)
registered the height of the jump of each athlete. Subjects jumped without
moving their arms to isolate lower-limbs power. Each participant carried out
three jumps with a 30-second interval in-between each trail. Research
considered the best outcome out of the three jumps for analysis. Researchers
treated jump height as a performance indicator [19], once it represents high
reproducibility [20].
The study used Borg’s CR-10 scale [21] adapted by Foster et al.
[22] (previously used in futsal athletes [13]) to obtain subjective perception
of effort (SPE) indexes 15-30 minutes after each match. Athletes answered the
question “What was your training session like?” using a scale that ranged from
0 to 10. To normalize internal load, such value was multiplied by the total
time length each athlete played actively on the court during each match.
The study used the Shapiro-Wilk test to verify data normality, Levene test to evaluate homoscedasticity, and Mauchly test
to check data sphericity. The research used measures of central tendency (mean)
and dispersion (standard deviation) to describe investigation variables. An
ANOVA of repeated measures compared the differences of CMJ, SJ, and PSE
variables in the after game, as well as Bonferroni's post hoc test. The study
adopted a significance level of p < 0.05 for every analysis and interpreted
data by using the statistical program Statistical Package for Social Science
(SPSS) 20.0®. In agreement with Hopkins [23], the research used magnitude-based
inference analyses to evaluate the differences of performance markers and SPE
concerning each match. Researchers assessed the smallest worthwhile change
(that is, 0.2 x initial standard deviation based on the effect size (ES)) and
determined confidence intervals (CI) of 90%. Possibilities of quantitative
changes (higher/trivial/lower) were evaluated qualitatively: < 1%, almost
certainly not; 1% to 5% very unlikely; 5% to 25% unlikely; 25% to 75% possible;
75% to 95% likely; 95% to 99% very likely; > 99% almost certain. The true
difference was evaluated as ‘clear’ when chances of obtaining positive or
negative results were > 10%. The study defined ES according to Cohen’s
classification [24]: < 0.2: trivial; 0.2-0.5: low; 0.5-0.8: moderate;
> 0.8: high.
Tables I and II present the average values of CMJ and SJ after each
match throughout the 4-consecutive-day championship. Research did not find
significant differences for both tests (p>0.05) among matches. However, the
magnitude-based inference analysis showed CMJ values concerning the 2nd match
were probably lower when compared to the 1st match (ES= -0.46 low) and the 4th
match (ES = -0.53 moderate). Furthermore, the 2nd match showed probably lower
values of SJ when compared with the 1st match (ES= -0.56 moderate) and possibly
lower compared with the 3rd match (ES = -0.45 low). Results were uncertain for
every other comparison.
Table
I – Values of mean and standard deviation of CMJ
performance after four-consecutive-day matches
Caption:
CMJ = Counter Movement Jump; cm = centimeters; J = match; ES = effect size; CI
= confidence interval; % = percentual
Table
II - Values of mean and standard deviation of SJ
performance after four-consecutive-day matches
Caption:
SJ = Squat Jump cm = centimeters; J = match; ES = effect size; CI = confidence
interval; % = percentual
Figure 1 displays the mean values of jumps (previously reported) and SPE
of sessions after each match. The study found significant differences between
the relative means of the 1st and 2nd matches (F = 158.486; p=0.04); 1st and 3rd
matches (F = 158.486; p = 0.01); and 3rd and 4th matches (F = 158.486; p = 0.01).
Moreover, the 1st match presented very likely and almost certain lower values
when compared with the 2nd (0/3/97; ES = -0.97 high) and the 3rd match (0/0/100;
ES = high), respectively; the 2nd match delivered possibly lower values when compared
with the 3rd match (5/21/75; ES = -0.45 low); the 4th match presented SPE
results probably and very probably lower than the 2nd match (2/7/91 EF = -0.83)
and the 3rd match (99/1/0; ES= 1.01 high).
aProbably
low and moderate CMJ effects relating the 1st and 4th matches, respectively; aProbably moderate SJ effect relating to the 1st
match; b Possibly low SJ effect relating the 1st match. *p < 0.05
significantly different SPE of session between the 2nd and the 3rd matches; #p
< 0.05 significantly different SPE of session relating the 3rd match; avery likely and almost certain high effect
relating the 1st match respectively; bpossibly
low effect relating the 2nd match; cVery
likely high effect relating the 4th match; dProbably
high effect for SPE of session
Figure
1 - Jump performance (centimeters) (CMJ colored circles; SJ white circles)
and SPE (arbitrary units) (painted squares) after matches
This study aims to analyze the effects of 4-consecutive-day futsal
matches in the neuromuscular performance of under-17 futsal athletes through
vertical jump tests. Its main results pointed decreased CMJ performance (2nd
match vs 1st and 4th matches), decreased SJ performance (1st match vs 2nd and
3rd), associated with higher SPE after the 2nd and 3rd matches.
Relating jumping performance, such findings corroborate with Freitas et
al. [25], carried out with male adult futsal athletes who played
4-consecutive-day matches. Results showed reduced performance in vertical jump
tests, and decreased RESTQ-Sport score related to physical recovery throughout
the competition, suggesting fatigue accumulation along the consecutive-day
matches. Andersson et al. [26] investigated recovery time concerning
muscular fatigue and biochemical alterations between two female soccer matches
with an active or passive recovery interval in-between them. When comparing
both matches, the authors pointed out significant performance decrease relating
sprint, CMJ, and peak torque. They did not find significant differences in
recovery standards between groups. Such results confirm Ronglan,
Raastad & Borgesen [27]
that investigated neuromuscular fatigue levels after three-consecutive-day
matches, demonstrating significant reduction (4-7%) of strength and speed levels.
The incomplete restoration of performance in-between matches and training
sessions explains slow recovery rates.
Other collective sports have also suggested performance reduction in
consecutive-match situations. When analyzing the efficiency of recovery
strategies throughout a 3-consecutive-day basketball tournament, Montgomery et
al. [28] reported performance decrease in sprint (0.7%) and agility tests
(2.0%), as well as reduced vertical jump after the first day of competition,
which remained suppressed even after tournament. More recently, Pereira et al.
[29] analyzed game performance, muscular damage, and neuromuscular fatigue in
three simulated matches carried out in a same day with rugby athletes from the
Brazilian Rugby Team. Results demonstrated increased levels of creatine kinase
(CK) after game, and increased SJ, CMJ, and strength development rates
concerning pre and post consecutive games values. Gallo-Salazar et al. [30]
pointed out neuromuscular reduction concerning lower limbs (jumps and speed)
and higher limbs (isometric strength and movement amplitude) on the day after a
consecutive tennis match competition.
Within a physiological point of view, increased capability of strength
production may be associated with high-intensity efforts, such as maximum
sprints, braking, and direction changing [1,2]. Furthermore, exhaustive
exercises with movement patterns involving CAE may induce muscular alterations
with consequent reflex alterations that may lead to performance decrease in
vertical jump [31]. Horita et al. [32] pointed
out increased sensibility to CAE tests concerning fatigue due to such exercises
when compared with testes involving concentric actions exclusively. On the
other hand, adaptations occasioned by constant specific training for a
determined sport may lead to a protective effect of repetitive exercise,
reflecting in lower damaging alteration in jumps [33]. In our study, vertical
jump tests showed to be sensible when identifying muscular function decrease
throughout matches, specially concerning SJ tests.
Performance decreased in the 2nd and 3rd matches as SPE increased in the
same matches (figure 1). Such findings agree with other studies about team
sports [12,34,35]. Rowsell et al. [34]
associated performance decrease to SPE and lower-limbs muscular pain increase
in consecutive matches. Furthermore, according to Moreira et al. [12,35], high
SPE values may be related to stress increase in volleyball and basketball
athletes after matches concerning the intensity and importance of a
competition.
Reductions in physical and technical performance may be related to
neuromuscular and mental fatigue [36,37]. Literature has been demonstrating
that mental fatigue limits one’s influence over maximum voluntary activation
and strength, explosive power, and anaerobic capacity [38,39]. Furthermore,
prolonged periods of cognitive activity may also induce mental fatigue rise
[37]. Therefore, it is likely that the athletes’ performance in vertical jumps
after the 2nd and the 3rd matches relates to SPE increase. Once this scale
represents a psychophysical measure [41], when approaching it, we must consider
both stimulus (workload) and perceptive response. Smith, Marcora,
and Coutts [39] demonstrated that an increased perception of effort mediates
the negative effects of mental fatigue.
Thus, an athlete’s SPE seems to be an easy-applicable low-cost
instrument that enables coaches and physical trainers to evaluate and compare
stress levels related to several development aspects [1,2,12,13]. SPE is a
scale that quantifies internal load. Internal load reflects the integration of
peripherical (muscles and joints) and central signs (ventilation) that, when
interpreted by using a sensorial cortex, produce the general or local
perception of effort to carry out a determined task [21].
The 4-consecutive-day championship analyzed has led to neuromuscular
performance decrease in vertical jump tests throughout the competition in
under-17 male athletes, associated with their increased effort perception. Such
results may help coaches and physical trainers planning and prescribing
training, especially concerning the characteristics of such tournament, that
requires high physical and mental effort during matches.
Deeper studies concerning physical and physiological responses
(intensity, game actions, training time length) associated with technical
aspects must be carried out for better understanding the relation of these
variables.
Acknowledgements
We thank Fundação Araucária
for granting part of the resources to carry out this study (Grant 215/2013).