Rev Bras Fisiol Exerc 2022;21(1):36-47
doi: 10.33233/rbfex.v21i1.4945ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Anxiety, sleep quality, and eating disorders in rhythmic gymnasts of the
Brazilian Youth Team
Ansiedade, qualidade
de sono e transtornos alimentares em ginastas rítmicas da Seleção Brasileira
Juvenil
Vinícius Oliveira Menezes1,
Igor Leite Marques1, Raquel de Jesus Silva1
, Marcia Regina Aversani Lourenço2,
João Henrique Gomes1, Renata Rebello Mendes1
1Universidade
Federal de Sergipe, Aracaju, SE, Brasil
2Universidade
do Norte do Paraná (UNOPAR), Londrina, PR, Brasil
Received: September
29, 2021; Accepted: November
24, 2021.
Correspondence: Renata Rebello Mendes, Universidade
Federal de Sergipe, Departamento de Nutrição (DNUT), Av. Marechal Rondon, s/n Jardim
Rosa Elze, 49100-000 São Cristóvão SE
Vinícius
Oliveira Menezes: vinimamute1999@gmail.com
Igor Leite
Marques: igorlmarquesufs@gmail.com
Raquel de
Jesus Silva: raqueljs@live.com
Marcia
Regina Aversani Lourenço:
marcia.aversanilourenco@gmail.com
João
Henrique Gomes: profjhgomes@gmail.com
Renata
Rebello Mendes: remendes@academico.ufs.br
Abstract
Introduction: The high training load associated with the aesthetic
standards required by rhythmic gymnastics (RG) has been considered a stressor
for high-performance athletes, which may culminate in anxiety, poor sleep
quality and risk for developing eating disorders. Objectives: To
evaluate the state of anxiety, sleep quality and the risk of eating disorders,
and their possible correlations, in high-performance rhythmic gymnasts looking
for a place in the Brazilian youth team. Methods: Twenty-one female
gymnasts (13.4 ± 0.5 years, 1.56 ± 0.1 m, 45.6 ± 6.1 kg) were evaluated. The
gymnasts answered three questionnaires: the Competitive Anxiety State Inventory
(CSAI-2) to assess cognitive and somatic anxiety as well as self-confidence,
the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI), and the Eating Attitudes Test (EAT
-26) to assess the risk of eating disorders. Results: Gymnasts
predominantly presented low somatic and cognitive anxiety, and high
self-confidence. However, 23.8% of rhythm gymnasts were at risk for eating
disorders, and 23.8% had poor sleep quality. There was a statistically
significant correlation between sleep quality and somatic anxiety, but eating
disorders did not correlate with anxiety or sleep quality. Conclusion:
The high-performance juvenile rhythmic gymnasts evaluated in this study
presented high frequencies for risk of eating disorders and poor sleep quality,
and monitoring by a multidisciplinary team was indicated.
Keywords: gymnastic; feeding behavior; adolescent; anxiety;
sleep wake disorders.
Resumo
Introdução: A elevada carga de treinamento
associada ao padrão estético exigido pela ginástica rítmica (GR) tem sido
considerada um fator estressor para as atletas de alto rendimento, podendo
culminar em ansiedade, má qualidade de sono e risco para desenvolvimento de
transtornos alimentares. Objetivos: Avaliar o estado de ansiedade, a
qualidade do sono e o risco de transtorno alimentar, e suas possíveis correlações,
em ginastas rítmicas de alto rendimento em busca de uma vaga na seleção
brasileira juvenil. Métodos: Foram avaliadas 21 ginastas do gênero
feminino (13,4 ± 0,5 anos, 1,56 ± 0,1 m, 45,6 ± 6,1 kg). As ginastas
responderam a três questionários: o Inventário do Estado de Ansiedade
Competitiva (CSAI-2) para avaliar ansiedade cognitiva e somática como também a
autoconfiança, o Índice de Qualidade do Sono de Pittsburgh (PSQI), e o Teste de
Atitudes Alimentares (EAT-26) para avaliar o risco de transtornos alimentares. Resultados:
As ginastas apresentaram predominantemente baixa ansiedade cognitiva e
somática, e elevada autoconfiança. No entanto, 23,8% das ginastas rítmicas
apresentaram risco para transtornos alimentares, e 23,8% apresentaram má
qualidade de sono. Houve correlação estatística significativa entre qualidade
de sono e ansiedade somática, porém os transtornos alimentares não se
correlacionaram com ansiedade ou qualidade de sono. Conclusão: As
ginastas rítmicas juvenis de alto rendimento avaliadas neste estudo
apresentaram altas frequências para risco de transtorno alimentar e má
qualidade de sono, sendo indicado monitoramento por equipe multidisciplinar.
Palavras-chave: ginástica; comportamento alimentar;
adolescência; ansiedade; transtornos do sono.
Rhythmic gymnastics
(RG) is a prominent sport in Eastern Europe, with a focus on the execution of
harmonious and graceful series, through the combination of body dynamics with
the handling of official equipment such as balls, clubs, ribbons, bows, and
ropes [1,2]. As it is a combination of extremely difficult body movements, with
high skill in handling devices, in coordination with musical accompaniment, RG
requires high levels of flexibility, power, coordination, and technical
perfection. Therefore, rhythmic gymnasts have a high training load, and in some
cases, inadequate periods for recovery [3,4], which has been considered a
source of mental and physical stress, capable of impairing the quality of sleep
of athletes, and consequently, their sporting performance [5,6].
Parallel to the demand for
physical performance imposed by RG, there is a requirement related to the
aesthetic standard of this modality, described as a slender body with long
limbs, according to the international standard of high-level gymnasts who won
Olympic medals [7]. Additionally, performance in high-performance acrobatic
modalities can benefit from reduced body weight, as leaner athletes seem to
have biomechanical advantages [8]. Thus, whether for aesthetic appeal or the
biomechanical advantages, the search for weight reduction has been frequently
reported in studies that evaluate rhythmic gymnasts [7] and, for this reason,
athletes of this modality may present a higher risk of developing eating
disorders and, consequently, harm to health [9].
The demands inherent to
performance, the perfection of movements, and the thin biotype imposed on
rhythmic gymnasts have been considered stressors in their routine and can be
linked to anxiety, poor sleep quality, and eating disorders [3,5,6], which
suggests the possibility of correlation between these variables.
In an attempt to assess the
correlation between eating disorders and anxiety in athletes, some studies were
carried out with team sports such as basketball and volleyball [10,11], combat
sports such as judo [12], and aesthetic modalities such as artistic gymnastics
[13], still, the results are controversial. However, to date, our searches have
not found studies that have assessed the correlation between anxiety, sleep
quality, and eating disorders in rhythmic gymnasts. Therefore, the present
study aimed to evaluate the state of anxiety, sleep quality, and the risk of
eating disorders, and their possible correlations, in rhythmic gymnasts undergoing
an evaluation process to compose the 2020-21 Brazilian Youth Team.
Experimental design
This is a
cross-sectional observational study. A week before the study was carried out,
the rhythm gymnasts and their guardians participated in remote meetings through
digital platforms to be guided regarding the objectives and procedures inherent
to the study. At this same stage, the Informed Consent Form (ICF) was sent for
those responsible for the athletes to sign. Still, in the week before the 2nd
National Rhythmic Gymnastics Internship, the athletes who agreed to participate
in this study and had the ICF signed by their guardians carried out food
records for three non-consecutive days so that the dietary characterization of
the studied group could be performed. After the first phase of clarification
and food records in remote mode, the gymnasts arrived in Aracaju, SE to
participate in the event. On the first day, another stage of characterization
of the participants was carried out through the body composition assessment. On
the second day, the gymnasts answered two questionnaires to assess the quality
of sleep and the state of anxiety, about 40 minutes before starting the
physical training in which they would be evaluated to make up the Brazilian
team. On the third day, the gymnasts filled out a questionnaire to assess the
risk of eating disorders and continued training for another four days to
compete for the seven places available to make up the Brazilian Youth Rhythmic
Gymnastics Team in 2021.
Sample
Twenty-one juvenile rhythmic
gymnasts, female, aged between 13 and 14 (13.4 ± 0.5 years) participated in the
study, invited to the 2nd National Rhythmic Gymnastics Internship, organized by
the Brazilian Gymnastics Confederation, held in December 2020, in Aracaju, SE,
whose objective was to select seven athletes to compose the Brazilian Youth
Team in the year 2021. The call criterion for the Internship, and, therefore,
the inclusion criterion for this study, was that the gymnast stood out (first
to third place in the classification) in the 2019 Brazilian Championships. The
exclusion criteria were: a) the use of drug therapy for anxiety disorders
treatment, sleep disorders, and eating disorders; b) absence at any stage of
the assessments inherent to the study.
Sample characterization, body composition and dietary assessment, body
composition assessment
For body composition
assessment, body weight, height, and skinfold measurements were taken in
triplicate; and later used to estimate the percentage of fat mass through the Slaughter
et al. equation [14]. Weight and height were measured on an analog scale,
with a coupled stadiometer (Toledo®), with a precision scale of 100 g and 1.0
cm, respectively. For estimating the percentage of body fat (%FM), the triceps
and subscapular skinfolds were measured with a scientific adipometer
(Sanny®), with a precision of 0.1 mm.
For data collection,
safety protocols were adopted to prevent contamination by SARS-CoV-2, such as
the negative RT-PCR test presentation by athletes and the team of professionals
involved in the collection, masks, 70% alcohol hand sanitizer, open and
ventilated environments.
Dietary assessment
A food record of three
alternate days [15] was adopted, with subsequent adoption of the Dietpro software to estimate caloric intake and nutrients
such as vitamin C, Calcium, Iron, Selenium, Zinc, and Magnesium.
Anxiety state assessment
The Competitive State
Anxiety Inventory (CSAI-2) translated version was adopted [16]. The assessment
consists of the 27 questions analysis distributed over 3 subscales, with 9
items each, namely cognitive anxiety, somatic anxiety, and self-confidence.
According to Paludo et al. [17], cognitive
anxiety is defined as the mental aspect of competitive anxiety, characterized
by pessimistic expectations and negative self-assessments about one's
performance. On the other hand, somatic anxiety is defined as the affective and
physiological component of anxiety, compromising the autonomic nervous system.
Finally, self-confidence anxiety is defined as the opposite state of cognitive
anxiety, that is, the individual's belief in their abilities to achieve
positive performance. Each item was scored according to the answer (none = 1
point; something = 2 points; moderate = 3 points; a lot = 4 points) [16,17].
For the analysis of cognitive, somatic, and self-confidence anxiety, the
following scores were considered: low = 9 to 18 points, average = 19 to 27
points, high = 28 to 36 points [16,18].
Sleep quality assessment
The Pittsburgh Sleep Quality
Index (PSQI) translated version was adopted to assess sleep quality [19,20].
This assessment was based on 19 self-classified items present in the
questionnaire, combined to form seven “component” scores, each of which ranges
from 0 to 3 Points. PSQI scoring ranges vary from 0 (zero) to 21 points. A
total score equal to or less than 5 points is associated with good sleep
quality, while a total score higher than 5 points is considered an indicator of
poor sleep quality [20].
Eating disorder risk assessment
The Eating Attitudes Test
(EAT-26) translated version was used to measure symptoms of different eating
disorders and assess the risk [21,22]. The questionnaire contains 26 questions
with individual scores ranging from 0 to 3 points, depending on the choice
(always = 3 points; often = 2 points; sometimes = 1 point; a few times, rarely,
and never = 0 points). A final score higher than 21 points indicates a risk of
eating disorders [21,22].
Statistical treatment
Normality was verified by
the Shapiro-Wilk test. Data are presented as mean and standard deviation. Relative
frequency was used in the assessments of the degree of anxiety, sleep quality,
and risk of eating disorders. Pearson's correlation coefficient was adopted to
identify the relationship between ratings of anxiety, sleep, and eating
disorders. All analyzes were performed using SPSS-22.0 software (IBM, SPSS
Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). Significance was set at p < 0.05.
Ethical aspects
The research was approved by
the Ethics and Research Committee, accredited by the National Health Council
(CAAE 16452219.5.0000.5546 2020). Those responsible for the participants read
and signed the Free and Informed Consent Form before the study was carried out.
Table I presents the
characterization data of the participants: age, body composition and energy
intake, macronutrients, and micronutrients of interest.
Table I - Characterization of the sample (mean ± standard
deviation) regarding age, RG training experience, body composition, and dietary
intake of the evaluated rhythmic gymnasts (n = 21)
Table II shows that the
means obtained in the cognitive and somatic anxiety subscales were less than 18
points (low anxiety) and that the mean obtained in the self-confidence subscale
was greater than 28 points (high). The same table shows that the sleep quality
index average was less than five points (good sleep quality), and the eating
attitudes test average was less than 21 points (no risk of eating disorders).
Table II - Descriptive statistics (mean ± standard
deviation, 95% confidence interval) of scores obtained by rhythmic gymnasts on
anxiety scales (CSAI-2), Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI), and Eating
Attitudes Test (EAT-26)
Table III shows the
bivariate correlations between all study variables. Only a significant (p <
0.05) positive correlation was found between somatic anxiety and PSQI scores,
indicating that the sleep quality of rhythmic gymnasts directly correlates with
higher levels of somatic anxiety.
Table III - Bivariate correlations between scores obtained
by rhythmic gymnasts on anxiety scales (CSAI-2), Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index
(PSQI), and Eating Attitudes Test (EAT-26)
*Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2
extremities)
As shown in figure 1, in the
two subscales of anxiety, somatic and cognitive anxiety, there was a
predominance of classification as “low anxiety” (81% and 71.4%, respectively).
In the self-confidence subscale, the most frequent classification was “high
self-confidence”. Figure 2 shows that 23.8% of gymnasts had poor sleep quality,
and the same frequency was found for eating disorders risk.
Figure 1 – Distribution of gymnasts according to degrees of
cognitive anxiety, self-confidence, and somatic anxiety
Figure 2 – (A) Frequency of risk behaviors for eating
disorders. (B) Distribution of gymnasts according to sleep quality
The main findings of
the present study show that most athletes had cognitive anxiety and somatic anxiety
subscales at low scores and the self-confidence subscale at high scores. Poor
sleep quality was found in 23.8% of gymnasts, and the same frequency for risk
of eating disorders. There was a significant correlation between somatic
anxiety and poor sleep quality. However, none of the variables correlated with
the risk of eating disorders.
Bertuol
and Valentini [23] reported that a very anxious
athlete may have higher energy expenditure due to greater muscle tension, as
well as difficulties in coordination, concentration changes, and narrowing of
the attention field, which can limit their ability to observe the general
competitive context. Such impairments can lead to a “de-automated” performance
of complex movements, making them more rudimentary. Therefore, it is believed
that the low frequency of cognitive anxiety and somatic anxiety found in our
study may have positively contributed to the performance of the evaluated
gymnasts. Similarly, Silva and Paiva [5] evaluated elite Portuguese rhythmic
gymnasts and also did not find high levels of anxiety, predominantly moderate.
The association between high
self-confidence and low somatic and cognitive anxiety, found in the present
study, corroborates the multidimensional theory of anxiety proposed by Martens,
Vealey, and Burton (1990) and discussed by Santos et al. [24], who
infers that cognitive and somatic anxieties are low when indices and
self-confidence are high.
According to Souza,
Teixeira, and Lobato [18], experience in the competitive environment directly
interferes with anxiety scores in athletes, with the youngest and least
experienced being those with higher scores for cognitive anxiety and somatic
anxiety and the most experienced being those who have greater self-confidence. Although,
in our findings, young athletes were evaluated, with an average of 13.4 years
old, these gymnasts had an average of 6.3 years of experience in the modality.
Additionally, it is relevant to emphasize that the criterion for inclusion in
this study was specifically to stand out in national and international
championships. Therefore, it is believed that the time and level of experience
of rhythmic gymnasts were determinants for the low frequency of cognitive and
somatic anxiety. Although the present study has presented new findings for the
national literature, it is important to consider evidence that young people may
not respond reliably to the assessment instruments. Even though gymnasts are
instructed to be trustworthy in their answers, the fact that they are being
evaluated at the national level can influence the answers to the
questionnaires.
Additionally, it was
found that 23.8% of gymnasts had poor sleep quality. According to Vitale et
al. [25], low quality of sleep may imply changes in neurocognitive,
metabolic, immunological, and cardiovascular functions, as well as negatively
affect athletic performance. Previous studies carried out with athletes
indicated a frequency of poor sleep quality between 28-77% [5,26,27,28], which is
higher than the frequency found in our study. Benjamin et al. [26]
report that sleep quality can affect athletes of different genders differently,
with women being more affected, with significantly higher levels of tension,
depression, anger, fatigue, confusion, and total mood disturbance, as well as
higher levels of stamina when compared to those with good sleep quality. It is
noteworthy that in this study, female athletes were studied, and, therefore, it
would be essential to monitor, in the future, the possible implications on
their mood.
Although the prevalence
of poor sleep quality found here has been lower than that found in similar
studies, it is necessary to emphasize that practically a quarter of the
evaluated gymnasts had this diagnosis, which may mean a loss of performance for
a member of the Brazilian team since a set of RG is
composed of five athletes. For a modality that requires perfection and
synchrony between the athletes, any mistake made by an athlete can affect the
overall score [1]. Therefore, we believe that these results justify the need
for monitoring the athletes by a multidisciplinary team.
Additionally, it was found
that somatic anxiety was significantly correlated with poor sleep quality.
Somatic anxiety refers to physiological reactions such as muscle tension,
tachycardia, discharge, tremors, and sweating, and such physiological changes
can negatively influence sleep quality [29], thus justifying our results.
We did not find a
correlation between eating disorders and the other variables. Studies carried
out with basketball [11] and judo [12] athletes to correlate anxiety with the
risk of developing eating disorders did not identify the influence of anxiety
on the development of eating disorders, as in the present study. The authors
assumed that the feelings of anxiety that athletes usually experience during a
competitive season do not explain the variance in risk behaviors for eating
disorders. Therefore, other factors may be related to this variable, such as
the constant search for the long biotype required in aesthetic modalities, such
as synchronized swimming, diving, skating, artistic gymnastics, and rhythmic
gymnastics. It is noteworthy that the sample size of our study is small.
Therefore, a larger sample would increase the possibility of observing
different correlations.
Although our findings did
not find a correlation between anxiety or sleep quality and risk behaviors for
eating disorders, it is essential to emphasize that practically a quarter of
the rhythm gymnasts evaluated were at risk for eating disorders. Recent studies
carried out with athletes have indicated a risk frequency for eating disorders
between 10-25% [11,12,30].
The prevalence of risk
behaviors for eating disorders in aesthetic sports athletes is higher than in
other sports [13,31]. Tan et al. [9] studied eating disorders in
gymnasts and found risk in 19% of those evaluated, this prevalence being lower
than that found in this study. The authors compared four different
questionnaires, namely the EAT-26, the Eating Disorder Exam Questionnaire
Version (EDE-Q6), the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI-II), and the Rosenberg
Self-esteem Scale, with a significant correlation between the EAT-26 scores and
those of the other instruments.
According to Wells et
al. [32], one of the main health risks of the athlete with an eating
disorder is the potential development of Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport
(RED-S), characterized by outcomes such as reduced resting metabolic rate,
decreased immunity and of protein synthesis capacity, damage to cardiovascular
health, as well as gastrointestinal, hematological, psychological, growth and
development alterations [33].
The low body fat and
dietary pattern of the participants, whose results indicate insufficient intake
of energy (< 50 kcal/kg) and nutrients such as carbohydrates (< 5 g/kg),
vitamin C (< 500 mg) [34], iron, calcium, zinc, and magnesium [35,36,37,38,39],
corroborate the risk of eating disorders. Therefore, it is possible to show
that the studied population is nutritionally vulnerable and should,
consequently, be monitored by an interdisciplinary team.
Our findings indicate
that the young rhythmic gymnasts evaluated presented low anxiety and high
self-confidence. However, there was a high frequency of poor sleep quality and
risk for eating disorders.
Conflicts of interest
No author had a financial relationship or any activity
outside the present study, which may appear to have influenced the submitted
work.
Authors' contribution
Conception and design of the research: Menezes VO, Lourenço MRA, Mendes RR;
Obtaining data: Menezes VO, Silva RJ, Marques IL. Data analysis and
interpretation: Menezes VO, Silva RJ, Marques IL, Mendes RR. Statistical
analysis: Gomes JH. Obtaining funding: Lourenço
MRA. Writing the manuscript: Menezes VO, Mendes RR. Critical review
of the manuscript for important intellectual content: Mendes RR, Gomes JH.